How to choose a vibration collar for deaf dogs: review of 4 popular models in 2021

Using a vibration collar is one of the best ways to bond with a deaf dogs and hearing impaired dogs. It helps you to draw the dog’s attention to yourself and “call” your dog. It is more humane towards animals, than a shock collar. 

In this article, I will show you how to choose the best vibration collar for deaf dogs in 2021 and how to train your dog with such a collar.

vibration collar for deaf dogs

How it works with the deaf dogs

All vibration collars have roughly the same principle of work. It has a vibrating module with rubber-metal prongs through. The set includes a remote control, with which the dog owner can activate the device at the right time.

Vibrations are absolutely harmless to deaf dogs and do not cause pain. Therefore, you can safely use it and not worry about your dear pet.

This signal just attracts the dog’s attention. You need to teach your pet to look at you or look for you when it senses vibration. Then you have eye contact with the dog and you can give commands with your hands. With the time passed, the dog will understand that the vibrations mean that the owner wants to tell it something. It is a great way to train deaf dogs. 

I recommend dog’s owners to learn the instructions for using the vibrating collar thoroughly, because if you make the wrong actions, you will not succeed. You should also train your deaf dog to understand visual signals and body language.
women using sign language for deaf dog

Tips to choose the best vibration collar

The following tips will help you when choosing a vibration training collar for your deaf dog:

  1. Some models combine multiple functions such as shock and vibration. Buy exactly vibrating collars that have no shock setting. In such vibrating dog collars, you can usually adjust the variant and the strength of the vibrations. Moreover, these ones are cheaper.
  2. There are vibrating collars that work automatically from a dog’s barking and those that are turned on using the remote control. So choose the second option.
  3. Measure your dog’s neck to make sure the collar is of the right size. It should not be too tight. Check that 1-2 fingers fit there.
  4. Pay attention to the material from which the strap is made. Experience has shown that it is best for dogs to have straps made of high-quality plastic.
  5. Choose a training collar with the minimum effective range of 500 feet. This is the maximum distance at which the collar can be operated using the remote control. If this parameter is high, then it will be possible to use the device outdoors.
  6. Training collar for deaf dogs must be waterproof. The dog can wet it at any time. Also playing outside, you can get caught in the rain, then the collar will break. That’s why it is better to buy a waterproof model.
  7. Read reviews for each product, watch a video review from those people who have already bought such a vibrating collar. Pay attention to positive and negative reviews.
  8. Good collars should have multiple vibration modes. You can adjust the intensity of the vibrations if you think they are not strong enough. Make sure your dog pays attention to you.
  9. An advantage will be the presence of some additional functions, for example, a sound mode. For deaf dogs it is useless, but you can still use this function to find your dog.

It is not worth buying the cheapest models. Remember — a miser pays twice. Cheap electronics don’t last long. Buy models at the average price or at the highest price if you can afford it. 

5 best vibration collars for deaf dogs

In accordance with the given characteristics, I have selected several current models of vibration collars for deaf dogs in 2021.

ModelType of StimulationRangeCharging time and battery lifeSizePrice
Educator E-CollarAudio tone, tapping sensation similar to vibration.1/2 mile range2 hours fully charging.For dogs 5 pounds and larger.$179.99
GoodBoy Mini No Shock Remote CollarBeep and vibration mode.Up to 330 yards.2 hours fully chargingbattery life – up to 7 days.For dogs 5-15 lb.55,67 $
SportDOG Brand 425 Remote Trainers (SD-425X)Vibration (buzz), tone (beep), or 21 levels of static simulation.Up to 500 yards.Fast charging for 2 hours, grabs 50-70 hours of use.Suitable for dogs weighing more than 8 pounds and neck size – 5-22 inches.$169.95
PetSafe Remote Training CollarTone, vibration and 15 levels of static.300 yards.Quick charge for 2 hours,40-hour battery life.Fits dogs 8 lb and up with neck sizes 6-23 in.$159.95

GoodBoy Mini No Shock Remote Collar – 55,67 $

It’s the best vibrating collar for small dogs 5-15 lb and puppies. It humane dog training collar has beep and vibration mode with nine levels of vibration. This is a big plus that you can customize the appropriate power of vibrations for your deaf dog.

good boy vibrating collar

Also, the advantages of this model include low cost, long battery life and beautiful design.

Other model characteristics:

  • range up to 330 yards (1000ft);
  • waterproof;
  • 2 hours fully charging;
  • battery life up to 7 days.

For now, I have not seen any drawbacks in this dog training collar. It is a pity that they have no typical model for large dogs.

Educator E-Collar – $179.99

It uses audio tone and stimulation similar to a vibration with tapping. Such stimulation has greater efficiency, although for some deaf dogs it may be annoying. I like that Educator E-Collar has tracking lights. They will help to find a dog in the dark.

The E-collar from Educator has a strap made of durable material, biothane. It has 100 selectable stimulus levels, and this is a very useful feature. For dogs with thick or long fur, you can buy special contact points of another size.

Educator collar

A small transmitter similar to a stopwatch will be an invisible hand and will not distract your dog.

Specifications of Educator E-Collar:

  • created for dogs 5 pounds and larger;
  • 1/2 mile range;
  • strap size — 3/4″ x 30″;
  • 2-hour full charge;
  • shock resistant;
  • waterproof.

The relative drawback of this model is a high price. But products in Educator are assembled and tested in the United States. Therefore, the quality should be excellent.

SportDOG Brand 425 Remote Trainers (SD-425X) – $169.95

SportDog sells hunting dog gear, therefore, their products are distinguished by durability and high quality. This is noticeable even by the appearance of the collar and control panel. All its training collars are quite powerful, created for outdoor training.

sportdog training collar

Model characteristics:

  • 3 types of stimulation: vibration (buzz), tone (beep), or 21 levels of static simulation;
  • suitable for dogs weighing more than 8 pounds and neck size — 5-22 inches;
  • radius of action up to 500 yards;
  • waterproof;
  • fast charging for 2 hours, grabs 50-70 hours of use.

If you buy additional collars, you can train up to three dogs at the same time. 

A large drawback is that you will not be able to customize the level of vibration. I also consider the disadvantage, that in this model there is no screen on the remote. But SportDog has another, more expensive model with a small screen on the remote, which displays the settings and the charge level.

PetSafe Remote Training Collar – $159.95

The next no shock collar from PetSafe – no less popular company of pet products. Here is its characteristics:

  • range — 300 yard;
  • fits dogs 8 lb and up with neck sizes 6-23 in;
  • audible tone, vibration and 15 levels of static (includes a safety lock feature for higher levels);
  • quick charge for 2 hours;
  • 40-hour battery life;
  • waterproof;
  • The large font display is easy to read at any time of day or night.
petsafe vibrating collar

I consider a small disadvantage that the strap is made of nylon. Compared with materials in other models, it is worse. Also, this dog training collar does not have the ability to adjust the strange vibrations.

Also PetSafe offers another model of no shock collar, which are suitable for deaf dogs:

  • Remote Spray Trainer 3 in 1 with tone, vibration and citronella spray. This collar is effective up to 300 yards away and fits dogs 8 lb and up and adjusts to fit neck sizes up to 27 in.
  • Collars with 600 yards and 900 yards range for $179.95 and $189.95.

FAQ

If you’ve learned this buyers’ guide, let’s look at some frequently asked questions regarding vibration collars for deaf dogs.

Can I train deaf dogs without a vibrating collar?

This is possible, but a collar will make the process easier and will take less time to train.

Should I use the shock settings to train a deaf dog?

Some collars have vibration and shock functions. But it’s better not to use shock for deaf dogs. Your dog will feel pain or discomfort, which will not help you get closer to each other. Shock collars are designed to correct behavior.

Can a vibrating collar be used for barking problems?

There are two primary applications for vibration collars and they’re very distinct anti barking and communicate with dogs who are deaf.
Any purpose is acceptable but it’s important to select only one purpose for the dog collar that vibrates. If you attempt to make use of it for two and you send confused messages for your pet.

Is this method suitable for puppies?

A vibrating collar is suitable for older puppies. Follow the guide. In general, you should wait until your puppy is approximately 6 months old to use an electronic dog training collar.
Always begin slowly and watch carefully the reaction of your dog with the collar. Your dog should not feel discomforted even a bit. If it isn’t uncomfortable, wait until later, or think about alternatives.

Deaf dog training with a vibrating collar

You can’t expect to apply a vibrating collar to your dog and see immediate results. Like everything else it will require  time of training and introduction.

  • It is the first thing to do getting your pet familiar with wearing the collar just similar to how you would wear any other brand new collar for dogs.
  • Next, begin using the vibration feature and to teach your dog that it is you who creates the experience. One way to achieve this is to feed your dog treats while you trigger the vibration. This helps in creating an emotional connection with the sound.
  • After getting the dog comfortable with it, you are ready to begin providing only the rewards when your dog stares at you while you activate the vibration.
  • Once you’ve mastered that it is now time to put an element of physical distance between yourself and your pet by using the vibrating feature. Continue teaching your dog to gaze at you from a distance away. It will take time and patience to make your dog react consistently with the collar.

The dog may not be able to comprehend what is causing the vibration or where it’s emanating from, or whether the cause is you. The dog eventually will begin to associate the sound of the collar with food.

training dog with e-collar

Should you buy a vibrating collar for a deaf dog?

Many pet’s owners believe that shock collars can be used to teach the deaf dog. I do not believe in this and we are completely against using the shock collars for dogs that are deaf. There is a need to prepare a dog to avoid excessive barking or for regular behavior-training. When we teach dogs, they begin to follow the commands we give them and, if they’re not doing the things we expect from them, we have a reason to perform the same task.

As a result dogs will be able to associate the same command with this move, but the reverse is true for deaf dogs. They are unable to understand the command, however dogs are intelligent enough and they are able to associate hand signals with any actions. The vibrations are not a form of punishment for dogs. It is merely a way of reminding them to look at your hand, which is easy.

The complete training process cannot be based on the vibration collar; however, if you can train your dog to look at your hand when there is an emitted vibration, it can make it much easier to train your dog.

Deaf dogs usually spend more time in their training than other dogs So don’t too quickly assume that vibrating collars for dogs with hearing impairments are not working.

Recommend watching next video about training a deaf dog with vibrating collar:

Leave a Comment