Are you a dog owner or trainer looking for the best no-shock dog training collar? Then this guide is for you.
This article covers:
- Factors to consider when choosing a humane training collar.
- Reviews of the six best no-shock dog training collars.
Contents
Comparison Table
| Model | Range | Modes | Dog weights |
| Barkwise Ultrasonic Collar | 75 feet | Ultrasonic/Vibration/Sound | Suits all dog breeds |
| Paipaitek No Shock Dog Training Collar (good value for money) | 1600ft | Beep and 10 levels of vibration | 4 to 60 pounds |
| Paws Furlosophy no shock Dog Training Collar (best training collar for two dogs of all sizes) | 1000 ft | Vibration, beep and combo (8 levels) | 8 to 120 lbs |
| GoodBoy Mini remote collar (best training collar for small dogs) | 1000 ft | 9 vibration levels and 1 sound signal | 5 to 15 lbs |
| Paws Furlosophy collar (the strongest collar with the longest range) | 1900 ft | Tone, 16 levels of Vibration, Light | 22 to 100 lbs |
| WWVVPET Citronella Dog Training Collar with Remote (best spray collar) | 1000 ft | Spray/Vibration/Beep | All breeds of dogs over 8 lbs |
Types of no-shock dog training collars
There are different types of non-shock collars for dog training. The two main types are:
- Vibration Collars: Vibration collars are primarily designed to grab a dog’s attention and redirect their focus, rather than providing a correction for behavior. This makes them especially useful in training situations where you need to interrupt unwanted behavior and refocus the dog. For example, if you are teaching a dog the “no”.
- Spray Collars: These collars release a spray (often citronella) near the dog’s face when triggered. Since most dogs dislike wet noses and citrus smells, this discourages bad behavior effectively. The method can be seen as inhumane by some, as it involves spraying a substance directly at the dog’s face. Additionally, they may not work well in all environments, especially in windy conditions or with very strong-willed dogs.
- Ultrasonic collars: have also proven to be highly effective for dog training. These devices emit a high-frequency sound that is inaudible to humans but can capture a dog’s attention and discourage unwanted behavior. Many dog owners find them useful for stopping excessive barking and reinforcing commands in a gentle, non-invasive way.
Top no-shock collars
I’ve selected the best non-shock collars from proven manufacturers and with a large amount of positive feedback. I hope you’ll like one of them!
Best at All – Barkwise Ultrasonic Collar
BarkWise Anti-Bark Collar is one of the best options for training dogs. Unlike traditional collars that rely on vibration, BarkWise uses a more effective and humane method: ultrasound.
Some dogs don’t respond well to vibrations, and spray collars can be seen as inhumane, as they involve spraying a substance directly at the dog’s face. BarkWise avoids these issues by using ultrasound, a frequency that is undetectable to the human ear but highly effective in getting your dog’s attention.
BarkWise Anti-Bark Collar is primarily designed to help stop excessive barking, but thanks to its remote control, it can also be used for a variety of other training needs (biting, chewing, hunting, digging, fighting, jumping, etc.). In addition to the ultrasound feature, the BarkWise collar also offers vibration and audio modes, providing multiple options for training.
The collar also comes with a 60-day money-back guarantee and a one-year manufacturer’s warranty, giving you peace of mind.
Best value – Paipaitek No Shock Dog Training Collar
The Paipaitek No-Shock Dog Training Collar is an excellent choice for owners looking for a balance of affordability and effectiveness. With a remote range of up to 1600 ft, it allows training in open spaces like parks or backyards.
Its vibration and beep modes provide a gentle but firm correction, making it ideal for dogs that respond well to sound cues (and also for deaf dogs). Many users praise its durability and waterproof design, though some note that the vibration may not be strong enough for particularly stubborn dogs.
📌Many positive reviews confirm its effectiveness.
Best training collar for small dogs – GoodBoy Mini
This collar is an excellent choice for small to medium-sized dogs (weighing between 5 to 15 lbs). The lightweight design ensures it’s comfortable for extended use without causing discomfort.
The nine vibration levels and one sound level provide plenty of options to communicate with your dog without being too harsh. Some dogs may not respond well to the vibrations, and the lack of tactile feedback on the remote can be frustrating when trying to make quick adjustments.
📌 DO YOU KNOW? Vibration collars can be useful for training deaf dogs. Read my review of the best vibration collars for deaf dogs.
Most Powerfull – Paws Furlosophy collar
For those who need more power and range, the Paws Furlosophy collar is a fantastic option. It’s ideal for larger dogs (22 to 100 lbs) or those who have been through basic training and need more advanced communication tools.
With a range of up to 1950 ft, it’s perfect for off-leash training in larger outdoor areas. The variety of settings (tone, vibration, and light) gives you flexibility in how you train your dog, depending on what works best for them.
Best Citronella Dog Training Collar – WWVVPET
If your dog doesn’t respond well to vibration collars, the WWVVPET citronella collar could be the solution. This collar uses a spray to interrupt unwanted behavior, which is often less invasive than electric stimulation.
Spray collar is a gentle yet effective way to deter unwanted behavior like excessive barking. With additional vibration and beep modes, you can adjust the approach based on your dog’s response.
The kit includes a can of citronella spray. One refueling is enough for 30-35 sprays.
If you need a collar to stop excessive barking, check out my review of the best anti-barking collars.
Paws Furlosophy no-shock Dog Training Collar
This collar is an excellent choice for multi-dog households or anyone looking to train several dogs at once. The remote control can connect to multiple collars, making it convenient for owners of more than one dog.
The strap is adjustable and fits dogs of all sizes, from small breeds (8 lbs) to large dogs (up to 120 lbs). The collar offers three training modes — vibration, beep, and vibration-tone — each with eight adjustable levels, giving you flexibility in choosing the most effective method for your dog.
FAQ about no-shock collars
Are training collars safe?
Yes, training collars are safe and humane when used correctly. Always follow the manufacturer’s instructions and check your dog’s neck regularly to ensure there is no irritation.
How do no-shock collars work?
No-shock training collars help teach dogs good behavior by using gentle corrections like vibration, sound, or a spray instead of electric shocks. When a dog misbehaves, the owner activates the collar using a remote, or the collar automatically responds to certain actions like barking. The vibration or sound interrupts the behavior, allowing the owner to redirect the dog and reinforce positive training.
Why choose no-shock collars?
These collars provide a safer alternative to shock collars, using gentle stimulation to grab your dog’s attention and encourage good behavior.
Buying Guide: How to Choose the Right No-Shock Collar
- Check the size: Measure your dog’s neck to ensure a proper fit. A good collar should allow two fingers to fit between the collar and your dog’s neck.
- Closure type:
- Quick-snap: Lightweight but less durable.
- Buckle: Secure but less convenient to remove.
- Slip-on: Quick to remove in emergencies but not secure without a leash.
- Waterproofing: A waterproof collar is ideal for active dogs who enjoy swimming.
- Multiple modes: Some dogs respond better to different levels of stimulation, so adjustable intensity is useful.
- Anti-bark function: If excessive barking is an issue, choose a collar with a remote to ensure control over when it activates.
If you’re looking for a shock-free training collar, there are excellent options available. Compare features and select a collar that best suits your dog’s needs and your budget.
📌 Have you tried any of these collars? Share your experiences in the comments!
Save this article on Pinterest so you don’t lose it!